The request arrives in a familiar shape: “We had a portrait done of my mother in 2016. My father is ninety now. Can you paint him to go beside her?” It sounds like ordering the same thing twice. It is not. The first commission had one source of truth — your photograph. The second has two: your photograph, and a physical painting that has hung in daylight for a decade, in a frame you did not choose, at a size you cannot quote from memory. Everything after this is a decision about how closely the new canvas should agree with the old one.

Why a second portrait is a different commission

The failure mode is almost never a bad painting. It is a good painting that looks like a stranger next to its partner. Four things cause it, and only one is the painter's fault:

  • The size was remembered, not measured. People quote the frame. A 16 × 20 in canvas in 2½ in moulding is a 21 × 25 in object, and ordering “the same” from memory produces a visibly smaller painting once both are framed.
  • The colour was remembered as warmer. Varnish amber-yellows at roughly two to four points of blue loss per decade. A fresh canvas beside it reads cold and slightly grey.
  • The proportions differ by an inch. 16 × 20 in is 4:5; 20 × 24 in is 5:6; 24 × 36 in is 2:3. Pair two ratios and the horizons sit at different heights, which the eye reads as a mistake it cannot name.
  • The hand changed. Same studio, five years later, possibly a different painter with a tighter touch. Not a defect — but the reason a brief must describe brush scale rather than assume it.

The six variables that decide whether two canvases read as a set

Matching is not copying. You are aiming for the same family resemblance, not the same fingerprint. Six things are worth specifying:

VariableWhat the eye catchesWhat to send us
Canvas proportionsA 1 in difference in height between two frames hung togetherImage area, edge to edge, not the frame
Ground colourWarm ochre versus cool grey under the skin — the single biggest tellCanvas edge with a sheet of white paper against it
Flesh temperatureOne face pink, the other olive, in the same room lightTwo close-ups of hands and faces, daylight
Brush scaleBroad strokes beside fussy ones; a 1 in brush on a 2 in face reads as a sketchClose-up of a cheek or sleeve, 12 in away
Varnish and sheenOne canvas glares under a lamp, the other stays matteThe back of the canvas, and a raking-light photo of the surface
Light directionTwo people lit from different windows, hung side by sideWhich side the highlight falls on

In practice, variables two, three and five do most of the damage, and all three are solvable in the studio. Light direction is not: if the existing portrait is lit from the upper left, the companion must be too, even when your new photograph is not. Decide that before the mock-up, not after.

Start with the painting you already own

Before any photograph of the new subject, photograph the old canvas. Seven images, all on a phone, no filters or flash, indirect daylight:

  • The full front, square on, two to three metres back at 1× zoom,.
  • A raking-light shot: stand to one side so light crosses the surface. The only way a phone shows brush texture.
  • The back of the canvas, which usually carries stretcher dimensions in inches, a supplier stamp, sometimes the artist's name and date.
  • A close-up of a hand, an ear or a sleeve from about 12 in away, for brush scale.
  • The canvas edge with a sheet of white paper against it, so colour can be balanced later. Phone cameras drift warm indoors; the paper is the reference.
  • The wall itself, with the painting in place, in the light it actually lives in — morning or evening, lamp on or off.
  • The frame profile, side on, including depth. If you plan to frame both, this is the profile to match.

Then measure twice. The number that matters is the painted image area, edge to edge, in inches and centimetres — not the outer frame. Note the stretcher depth too: 3/4 in is standard, 1½ in is a gallery wrap, and it changes how a float frame sits.

Size arithmetic for two canvases

Three rules govern a pair. They share a height. They share a ratio. The gap between frames is 2–3 in, and the frames plus the gap are treated as one object spanning two-thirds to three-quarters of the furniture below. A pair hung at different centres looks drunk; both centres belong on the same line, 57–60 in from the floor.

PairTotal width with a 2.5 in gapSits overBoth canvases
2 × 12 × 16 in26.5 in36–40 in console$578
2 × 16 × 20 in34.5 in48 in sideboard$778
2 × 20 × 24 in42.5 in56–60 in sideboard$1,098
2 × 24 × 36 in75 in100 in wall or an 84 in sofa$1,578

Mixed sizes do not pair. A 16 × 20 in canvas is 20 in tall; a 20 × 24 in is 24 in tall. That four-inch step cannot be hidden by a frame — a float frame buys a quarter or half an inch at most. If the existing painting is 16 × 20 in, order 16 × 20 in, not “a bit bigger to be safe.” The one exception is a deliberate two-tier stack, where the mismatch is the point. The canvas-by-canvas reasoning is in the painting size guide.

Three cases, three different answers

A companion for a widowed parent

Paint the person at the age they were in the existing portrait, not at today's age, or the pair reads as a timeline rather than a couple. That usually means a photograph from the same decade — often a wedding print, scanned at 600 dpi, with the colour cast corrected before painting. Two 20 × 24 in canvases are $549 each; two 16 × 20 in are $389 each if the wall is a hallway. If only one usable photograph of the second person exists, say so early: a face 500 pixels wide is the practical floor, and the honest answer may be a smaller canvas.

Adding a grandchild to a set of cousins

Here the temptation is to improve on the original: a nicer background, warmer light, a larger canvas because this child is the most photographed. Resist all three. The set works because backgrounds and grounds are identical; a new “better” background turns a set into a collection. Order the same size, ground and chair, and send the original's photographs so the painter can see what is being joined.

A sibling wants their own copy

Usually the honest answer is a second original, not a reproduction. A hand-painted second canvas at the same size is $778 for two 16 × 20 in pieces; a high-resolution scan and giclée print is cheaper per copy but is a print, with a print's surface and lifespan. If three or more households want one, the arithmetic changes and prints start to make sense — the licensing side is covered in who owns a commissioned portrait. Either way, do not ask a painter to add a new person into the existing canvas: the seam shows in raking light, the original is altered for good, and a new canvas costs less than the repair.

Making the old painting meet the new one

Fresh paint beside a fifteen-year-old varnish will read cooler and slightly greyer, however carefully the palette is matched. Two honest routes, and one dishonest one:

  • Clean and re-varnish the older painting. A conservator removes the yellowed varnish and applies a fresh one, typically $150–$450 and two to four weeks, provided the paint film is stable. The only route that genuinely resets the clock.
  • Tint the new varnish slightly warm. A retouch varnish with a touch of amber brings a new canvas two or three points closer to an aged one. Cheap, reversible, usually enough.
  • Do not glaze the new painting brown to “age” it. It muddies flesh, kills the highlights, and cannot be undone without solvent on a young film. Any studio offering to antique a new portrait is solving the wrong problem.

Sheen matters far less than flesh temperature. Get the skin right and the varnish argument disappears in room light.

Framing them as a pair

Identical profile, finish and — if you can manage it — width of moulding. If the existing frame is ornate and discontinued, chasing a replica costs $250–$650 and takes weeks. Reframing both in a simple float frame at $90–$220 each is cheaper, looks deliberate, and absorbs a quarter-inch size difference through the float gap. The hanging arithmetic is in framing and hanging an oil painting.

The six-line brief

Send this and the studio has everything it needs to quote accurately:

  1. The seven photographs of the existing painting, in daylight, unfiltered.
  2. Image area in inches, plus stretcher depth and frame outer dimensions.
  3. Who the new subject is, at what age, and which photograph you want painted.
  4. What must be identical — ground, flesh temperature, brush scale, light direction — and what may differ.
  5. Where the pair will hang, the wall colour, and the gap you have in mind.
  6. Your deadline and your ceiling, stated as a number.

If the style question is still open — warmer and more classical, or looser and more painterly — the portrait style guide explains what each choice does to a face at a given canvas size, and the reference photograph guide covers what a phone can and cannot supply.

What matching cannot do

It cannot lend you the hand of an artist who has stopped painting, though a good studio can come close enough that only you will know. It cannot correct a colour cast in your phone photograph — hence the white paper. It cannot make a weak original composition stronger; if the first portrait is cropped badly, fix the crop in the new one rather than repaint the old. What it can do is put two people on one wall who look like they were painted by the same person, in the same room, in the same decade — which is the whole point.

How to start

Send the photographs of the existing painting through the quote form, with the image dimensions and where the pair will hang. You get a fixed price, a delivery date and a mock-up within 24 hours; how it works walks through the sequence, and custom portraits has the published price table. Nothing is charged until you approve the price and the mock-up — which, for a matching pair, is exactly when you want a second opinion.